Legalizing marijuana for medical or recreational purposes isnâ€™t associated with an uptick in traffic fatalities, according to a new study released this month.
Kansas State University graduate student Andrew Young looked at data on average traffic fatalities over 23 years and used two models to assess the impact of cannabis reform on road safety.
â€ś[L]egalizing marijuana is not found to be a statistically significant predictor of fatality rates,â€ť he concluded. â€śThis finding means that the legalization of marijuana for both medical and recreational purposes is not associated with either a reduction or increase in fatalities per 100,000 vehicle miles traveled.â€ť
After conducting a regression analysis that turned up no evidence that state legalization efforts result in an increase or decrease in traffic fatalities, Young used a difference-in-difference model to compare the traffic fatality rates in legal cannabis states and control states. The more tailored analysis covered an eight-year timeline, starting five years before the state in question legalized marijuana.
No concrete trends emerged from that analysis.
In Arizona, where medical cannabis is legal, average traffic fatalities mirrored those of Wyoming and South Dakota, where marijuana is prohibited.
The fatal car accident rate was considerably higher in Colorado compared to Georgia and Iowa in 2001, but that trend started happening prior to medical cannabis legalization and also leveled out by 2003.
Traffic fatalities dropped in Washington D.C. following the City Councilâ€™s 2010 approval of medical cannabis, and were lower than in Utah or Virginia, which prohibit marijuana.
â€śThe results of the analysis suggest that there is no statistically [significant] relationship between marijuana legalization and fatal crashes,â€ť Young wrote. â€śThese findings suggest that concerns of policy makers and the public that legalizing marijuana will worsen road safety are not entirely founded.â€ť
â€śAccording to the difference-in-differences model, the recent upward trend of traffic fatality rates nationwide is not a result of medical marijuana legalization. In fact, the legalization of marijuana is not found to be a predictor of traffic fatalities,â€ť he wrote.
The main limitation of the study, which has not been published in a peer-reviewed journal, concerns states where cannabis has been legalized for adult use. The small sample size, at least compared to medical marijuana states, means the analysis might not have been able to â€śfully estimate the impact of recreational cannabis on traffic safety.â€ť
That said, the findings reflect those of several past studies that have also failed to identify a statistically significant relationship between legalization and road safety.
Another recent study also debunked the myth that traffic accidents spike on the cannabis holiday 4/20.